Shared Leadership Is Infrastructure, Not a Courtesy

If Physicians Must Explain the Decision, They Need a Voice in Making It

Physicians explain decisions they did not make. The leaders who made those decisions are rarely in the exam room when patients ask why. That distance has consequences for everyone.

Consider a familiar scenario. A patient on active treatment opens her portal and finds that her infusion has moved from Tuesday to Thursday. She had arranged a ride, time off work, and someone to watch her kids around that Tuesday. The change came from a new scheduling template approved weeks earlier to balance chair capacity. It made sense on paper. No one told her why, and no one alerted her physician.

When she saw her physician, she did not ask about chair utilization. She asked whether two extra days would make her cancer worse. Her physician could answer the clinical question but had not been given the rationale for the scheduling change. She left reassured about her treatment and a little less sure about the system delivering it.

In the last issue, Accountability Without Authority Is Just Blame, I argued that physicians are not asking to be exempt from accountability. We are asking that accountability follow authority.

This issue takes up the design question that conversation raised: How do we build organizations where the people who answer for decisions have a meaningful role in shaping them? It is the next step from diagnosis to design that I promised in The Leadership Tax.

Most operational leaders I know are working under real constraints: thin margins, workforce shortages, regulatory requirements, and reimbursement that rarely matches the cost of care. Most physicians I know want their organizations to succeed.

The problem is how we have structured decision-making. Too often, authority sits in operations and finance while the obligation to explain the consequences lands in the exam room. When those functions are held by people who rarely sit at the same table, decisions carry a hidden cost that shows up later, in trust.

1. The decision-explanation gap

According to the Physicians Advocacy Institute and Avalere Health, 82% of U.S. physicians were employed by hospitals or other corporate entities as of January 2026, with 253,000 additional physicians becoming employees since 2018.¹ Employment alone does not tell us who controls a scheduling template or staffing decision. But it makes organizational governance increasingly consequential to how physicians practice.

That shift can work well when physicians have meaningful influence within those organizations. Survey findings suggest there is substantial room for improvement.

In CHG Healthcare’s 2025 Physician Sentiment Survey, 72% of physicians wanted input into decisions affecting their work, yet only 40% said executive leadership actively solicited it. While 57% trusted their direct supervisor, only 41% trusted executive leadership.²

A decision made without clinical input still reaches patients through clinical care. The physician may become its spokesperson without having seen the tradeoffs behind it, or having had an opportunity to identify consequences before implementation.

2. The gap has a human cost and a financial cost

The last issue described what misplaced accountability does to clinicians: moral injury, fractured teams, and a system that treats process failures as personal ones. Being asked to defend a decision you neither shaped nor understand adds another burden.

It asks a physician to spend patient trust on someone else’s tradeoff.

Research also connects leadership quality with physician well-being. In a Mayo Clinic study, each one-point increase in a composite rating of an immediate physician supervisor’s leadership was associated with a 9% higher likelihood of professional satisfaction and a 3.3% lower likelihood of burnout.³ The study does not establish causation or isolate shared decision-making, but it underscores the relevance of leadership behavior to physicians’ experience at work.

The financial stakes are substantial. In a 2019 modeling study, Han and colleagues estimated that physician turnover and reduced clinical hours attributable to burnout cost U.S. health care approximately $4.6 billion annually, or roughly $7,600 per employed physician at the organizational level.⁴ Those figures describe the broader cost of burnout, not the specific cost of excluding physicians from decisions.

Bain & Company’s 2017 report offers a more direct connection to participation. Physicians highly engaged in organizational decision-making gave their organizations a Net Promoter Score of +47, compared with −61 among those who were not engaged.⁵ That 108-point difference measures willingness to recommend an organization, rather than actual retention. It is still a signal leaders responsible for recruitment and retention should take seriously.

3. Shared leadership requires more than a title

Physician leadership deserves serious investment. Goodall’s analysis of highly ranked U.S. hospitals found an association between physician chief executives and higher hospital quality scores. But the study was cross-sectional and relied on a media-generated ranking; it could not establish that physician leadership caused better performance.⁶

Clinical and operational expertise are not mutually exclusive. Physicians can develop deep expertise in finance, strategy, and operations. The design question is how organizations bring the expertise a decision requires into the room, and give it meaningful authority.

One model designed to bring those perspectives together is the dyad: a physician leader and an administrative leader who share responsibility for a service line, department, or initiative.

The evidence requires some humility. A 2020 narrative review in the Journal of Health Organization and Management screened 307 articles and identified six relevant evaluations of dyad leadership. Much of the literature focused on implementation rather than demonstrating effects on patient or organizational outcomes.⁷

A small 2019 qualitative dissertation offers an illustration of a problem readers of The Leadership Tax will recognize. Among six participants, the two part-time physician leaders described role conflict and difficulty achieving shared leadership, while the administrative participants experienced shared leadership with their physician partners.⁸ The sample is too small to generalize, but the concern is worth examining.

A dyad in which one partner is expected to lead on evenings and weekends is not adequately resourced shared leadership. It is the leadership tax with a new title.

Physicians should have a meaningful role in shaping the decisions they are expected to explain to patients, and to other physicians.

Leadership implications

Physicians do not need another committee added to an already full schedule. They need a decision-making structure that prevents avoidable rework, workarounds, and lost trust. Four design choices offer a practical starting point.

Couple decision rights with explanation duties. Decisions that materially change patient access or clinical practice should have a named physician co-owner with defined authority before approval. That person needs a way to gather input from affected clinicians and bring it into the decision. Representation must carry influence, not simply responsibility for announcing the outcome. Include nursing, other frontline teams, and patient perspectives when the decision affects them.

Fund the physician side of the dyad as real work. Provide protected, compensated time sized to the responsibilities, with a corresponding adjustment in clinical expectations. Adding leadership duties to a full clinical workload recreates the problem the dyad was meant to solve.

Send the rationale with the decision. Every change that reaches the front line should arrive with a concise explanation of what is changing, why, and how patient concerns will be addressed. Include patient-ready language and a clear route for exceptions or unresolved questions. Physicians should not have to reconstruct the rationale at the bedside.

Close the loop and measure it. When physician input does not change a decision, explain why. Track physician trust in executive leadership alongside implementation problems, patient complaints, and rework. Review those findings with the same seriousness as throughput and margin—and use them to revise decisions when necessary.

A challenge for health system leaders

Name one decision your organization made in the last twelve months that physicians had to explain to patients without meaningful physician involvement in shaping it.

What did it cost in rework, frustration, or trust? What would it have taken to bring the right clinical perspectives into the room before the decision was final?

Next issue: What a dyad that genuinely shares power looks like, and how to build one.

Shikha Jain, MD, FACP | Hematologist-Oncologist | Associate Professor of Medicine, University of Illinois Chicago | Founder, Women in Medicine®

References

  1. Physicians Advocacy Institute and Avalere Health. Physician Employment Trends and Practice Acquisitions: 2018–2026.
  2. CHG Healthcare. Only 18% of Physicians Are Highly Engaged, New Study Finds. 2025.
  3. Shanafelt TD, et al. Impact of Organizational Leadership on Physician Burnout and Satisfaction. Mayo Clinic Proceedings. 2015.
  4. Han S, et al. Estimating the Attributable Cost of Physician Burnout in the United States. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2019.
  5. Bain & Company. Front Line of Healthcare Report 2017.
  6. Goodall AH. Physician-Leaders and Hospital Performance: Is There an Association?. Social Science & Medicine. 2011.
  7. Clouser JM, et al. Evaluating the Clinical Dyad Leadership Model: A Narrative Review. Journal of Health Organization and Management. 2020.
  8. Campanelli SM. The Lived Experience of Healthcare Leadership Dyads: Perceptions of Agency. EdD dissertation, University of New England. 2019.


This issue of Designing Modern Healthcare was first published on LinkedIn. Read and comment on the original, or subscribe to the newsletter.

About Shikha Jain, MD FACP

Dr. Shikha Jain, MD, FACP, is a triple board-certified hematologist-oncologist and tenured Associate Professor of Medicine at the University of Illinois Chicago, specializing in gastrointestinal cancers and neuroendocrine tumors. She is the Founder and Board Chair of Women in Medicine®, host of Healio's Oncology Overdrive podcast, and a national voice on healthcare delivery, physician leadership, and gender equity.

Leave a Comment